AJCSAustralian Journal
of Crop Science
November 2026 · Volume 20 · Issue 11

Research article · Oat cultivar resilience and crop protection

Less dependent Brazilian oat cultivars to fungicides during the grain filling stage

O. Alessi1, J.A.G. da Silva1, I.R. Carvalho*1, D.A. Magano2, C.F. Colet1, F. C. Pereira1, L. E. Panozzo2, V. Pansera1, C.L. Peter1, J.A. da Rosa1, T. P. Arenhart1, C.M. Babeski3, I. M. Zardin1, K. S. Thomas1

1 Regional University of the Northwest of the State of Rio Grande do Sul, Ijuí, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil

2 Federal University of Pelotas, Capão do Leão, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil

3 Federal University of Santa Maria, Santa Maria, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil

Corresponding author: carvalho.irc@gmail.com
Submitted: 22 December 2025 | Revised: 09 May 2026 | Accepted: 25 August 202620(11):958–971
In this article

Abstract

The use of resilient oat cultivars combined with the omission of fungicide applications during grain filling stage can enhance food safety while reducing environmental impacts. The objective of this research was to identify Brazilian oat cultivars with greater resilience to fungicides omission by evaluating necrotic leaf area and grain yield, considering the last fungicide application prior to the grain filling stage. Field experiments were conducted from 2015 to 2020, using a randomized complete block design arranged in a 22×4 factorial arrangement, consisting of 22 white oat cultivars (both currently recommended and no longer included in the current Brazilian recommendations) and four fungicide application regimes (no application; one application at 60 days after emergence (DAE); two applications, at 60 and 75 DAE; and three applications, at 60, 75, and 90 DAE), with three repetitions. The assessment of necrotic leaf area and grain yield indicated that URS Altiva, UPFPS Farroupilha and UPFA Gaudéria exhibited the highest resilient under conditions without fungicide application during the grain filling stage. These cultivars therefore represent promising genetic resources for enhancing food security and for use in agroecological and low-input production systems.

Keywords: Agenda 2030; Agroecological systems; Agronomic performance; Avena sativa; Disease tolerance; Genetic resources.
Abbreviations: SD_ standard deviation; S_ superior, represented by one SD above the mean; I_ inferior, represented by one SD below the mean; R2_ determination coefficient (%); *_ significant at 5% level by the t-test; AYC_ acceptable year for oat cultivation; FYC_ favorable year for oat cultivation; UYC_ unfavorable year for oat cultivation; GY_ grain yield (kg ha-1); WF_ without fungicide; CF1_ one fungicide application, at 60 days after emergence (DAE); CF2_ two fungicide applications (at 60 and 75 DAE); CF3_ three fungicide applications (at 60, 75, and 90 DAE); UYD_ unfavorable year for the development of foliar diseases; Min_ average minimum temperature; Max_ average maximum temperature; NLA_ necrotic leaf area assessed at 105 days after emergence;

Introduction

Oats are among the most widely cultivated cool-season crops in southern Brazil, serving multiple purposes, such as soil cover, crop rotation, and food production for animal and human consumption (Reginatto et al., 2021; Rosa et al., 2023). These combined functions, together with increased demand, have driven a substantial expansion cultivation area in recent years (Dornelles et al., 2021; Screminn et al., 2023). However, this increase in oat crop areas combined with genetic uniformity among cultivars has increased the susceptibility to diseases (Murphy et al., 2013; Basso et al., 2022). Among the diseases affecting oats, foliar diseases are greatest concern, as they cause necrosis of leaf tissues, the primary organs responsible for photosynthesis, thereby compromising plant development and grain yield (Dietz et al., 2019; Dornelles et al., 2020). Among foliar diseases, the fungi that cause leaf rust (Puccinia coronata Cda. F.sp. avenae) and helminthosporiosis [Drechslera avenae (Eidam) El Sharif] receive the most attention due to their ability to compromise the biological functions of the plant and grain yield (Nazareno et al., 2018; Dornelles et al., 2020).

The management of oat foliar diseases relies predominantly on fungicide applications since genetic resistance is often partial, unstable, or rapidly overcome by evolving pathogen population (Silva et al., 2015; Bhardwaj et al., 2021). Disease severity is generally higher during the flowering and grain filling stages when temperature and humidity conditions are particularly favorable for pathogen development (Basso et al., 2022; Pereira et al., 2023). As a consequence, fungicide use tends to intensify during these stages, sometimes extending applications close to physiological maturity (Jiang et al., 2021; Screminn et al., 2023). Moreover, most fungicides recommended for oat crops have systemic action, favoring the translocation of the pesticide to the grains during the grain filling stage (Rosa et al., 2023; Pereira et al., 2020). Therefore, this poses a potential risk to public health due to the close association between pesticides and emergence of diseases such as cancer, diabetes, respiratory diseases, and neurological and reproductive disorders (EFSA et al., 2021; Rani et al., 2021). The application of pesticides also has environmental consequences, including soil, water, and air pollution, as well as the death of important ecosystems organisms such as pollinating insects (Pereira et al., 2020; Screminn et al., 2023).

Throughout the crop cycle, plants are exposed to variable environmental conditions and pathogen pressure that may restrict growth and productivity (Jeschke, 2016; Khan et al., 2021). Nevertheless, certain cultivars can withstand, recover from, or adapt to these adverse conditions and are therefore considered resilient. Plant resilience corresponds to the ability to tolerate biotic and abiotic stresses, maintain plant growth and production even under unfavorable conditions (Husen, 2021; Waldron et al., 2021). Considering the context of diseases, some factors contribute to greater expression of resilience in plants, including the presence of resistance and tolerance (Patra et al., 2018; Bakala et al., 2020). Disease resistance involves the plant's ability to limit the entry, development, and reproduction of pathogens, whereas tolerance relates to the plant's ability to maintain growth despite infection (Mansilla-Córdova et al., 2018; Pagán and García-Arenal, 2018). Therefore, properly scheduled fungicide applications can facilitate the identification of more resilient oat cultivars to reduce the use of pesticides and extend the interval between the last application and grain harvest, promoting food security and minimizing environmental damage. The objective of this research was to identify Brazilian oat cultivars with greater resilience to fungicides omission by evaluating necrotic leaf area and grain yield, considering the last fungicide application prior to the grain filling stage.

Results and discussion

Agricultural year conditions and fungicide use in the expression of grain yield

The evaluated crop seasons exhibited distinct meteorological patterns that influenced disease pressure and nitrogen use efficiency. In 2015, high rainfall and temperatures above 18 °C throughout the cycle favored foliar diseases, reducing yield to 2,444 kg ha⁻¹ (below the 4,000 kg ha⁻¹ potential). Thus, 2015 was classified as an acceptable year for cultivation (AYC) and favorable for disease development (FYD). In contrast, 2016 presented lower, stable temperatures and well-distributed rainfall (Fig. 1), which limited leaf necrosis and optimized N utilization. With a yield of 3,867 kg ha⁻¹ (Table 1), 2016 was the only year classified as favorable for cultivation (FYC) and unfavorable for diseases (UYD).

The years 2017 to 2020 were characterized as unfavorable for cultivation (UYC) and favorable for diseases (FYD). In 2017 and 2018, water scarcity during early stages and high temperatures at nitrogen application led to volatilization losses, while subsequent rains during grain filling triggered severe disease outbreaks (Fig. 1). In 2019, high thermal averages and scarce initial rainfall restricted plant growth and nitrogen efficacy. Similarly, 2020 suffered from a prolonged drought after 50 days after emergence, which, combined with high temperatures, severely compromised yield.

Air temperature and relative air humidity are closely related to the emergence and progression of the main oat foliar diseases. Leaf rust, caused by the fungus Puccinia coronata Cda. F.sp. avenae, is the main oat disease and is most damaging at average temperatures above 18 ºC and at high relative air humidity (above 90%) (Nazareno et al., 2018). Yellow spot, caused by the fungus Drechslera avenae (Eidam) El Sharif, is favored by the occurrence of high air humidity and temperatures ranging from 18 to 28 ºC. Additionally, air temperature and relative air humidity have effects on the development of plants and crop yield. Relative air humidity is an important factor for grain yield, as it regulates the leaf blade transpiration rate can affect the water balance in crops (Ferrante and Mariani, 2018; Chia and Lim, 2022).

Air temperature also significantly affects crop yield. Milder temperatures and proper radiation favor tillering and grain filling. However, the occurrence of temperatures below 2 and 3 °C near the flowering stage can damage leaves and stems, causing flower sterility (Marolli et al., 2017; Mantai et al., 2021b). Low temperatures combined with frost during grain formation can arrest grain growth, resulting in grains of low industrial quality (Mantai et al., 2016). The occurrence of mild temperatures during the vegetative stage is considered essential for increasing the number of grains per panicle (Castro et al., 2012; Scremin et al., 2020).

Additionally, rainfall is the meteorological variable that most affects crop yield, as it is directly connected to plant development and has a significant effect on the efficiency of nitrogen utilization (Kraisig et al., 2020; Mantai et al., 2021a). Large rainfall volumes are not necessarily required to ensure high oat crop yield, but well-distributed rainfall throughout the crop cycle favors adequate soil moisture contents for the crop development processes (Marolli et al., 2018; Reginatto et al., 2021).

Descriptive statistics of necrotic leaf area and grain yield of oat cultivars

The means of necrotic leaf area under the different fungicide application conditions (Table 2), showed significant plant tissue damage by leaf necrosis, mainly under absence of fungicide application, except for the agricultural year 2016, which presented natural disease control conditions. The effect of applying fungicides is evident, resulting in decreased necrotic leaf area as the number of agrochemical applications was increased throughout all evaluated agricultural years. However, a similarity of necrotic leaf area among most cultivars was found between the treatments with two and three fungicide applications in the years with a strong disease pressure.

Overall, the cultivars that showed reduced means of leaf necrosis in a specific year, indicating a superior performance (S), did not consistently maintain this classification (Table 2). However, the cultivars that were consistently classified as superior under the different fungicide application conditions, regardless of the agricultural year, were URS Brava, URS Estampa, and FAEM 4 Carlasul, followed by URS Altiva and IPR Afrodite.

Table 1. Temperatures, air humidity, and rainfall depths during the oat crop cycle and means of grain yield and necrotic leaf area, according to the agricultural year.
MonthTemperature (°C)Air humidity (%)Rainfall (mm)GYNLAClass
MonthMinMaxMeanMinMaxMean30 years*Occurred(kg ha-1)(%)PlantDiseases
2015
May1323186896821611812,44432AYCFYD
June102116679682141228
July112116679581131211
August13251958937611186
September132117579476149127
October152520479270227161
Total------920994
2016
May112116659580161553,8675FYCUYD
June5191254947414110
July9221560927613180
August92316609276111160
September8231653907214956
October122519539172227326
Total------920687
2017
May1422187292821614341,86272UYCFYD
June112216649278141146
July8241643896613110
August112418549173111117
September152721609176149161
October142720569274227304
Total------9201172
2018
May132620599376161632,01392UYCFYD
June71913679581141104
July9201566958113180
August62013589376111107
September132519589476149184
October162520479270227243
Total------920781
2019
May1422186896821612021,62278UYCFYD
June12241850927114155
July8191355947413190
August8221548927011169
September11241748916914999
October152821479068227236
Total------920751
2020
May922155795761611731,30693UYCFYD
June112116729483141291
July81913689581131336
August102316589376111156
September12251860947714948
October14302244916722752
Total------9201,056

Min= average minimum temperature; Max= average maximum temperature; *= historical rainfall depth from May to October of the last 30 years; GY= grain yield; NLA= necrotic leaf area assessed at 105 days after emergence; AYC= acceptable year for oat cultivation; FYC= favorable year for oat cultivation; UYC= unfavorable year for oat cultivation; FYD= favorable year for the development of foliar diseases; UYD= unfavorable year for the development of foliar diseases.

Monthly rainfall and minimum and maximum air temperatures during oat cultivation across the 2015 to 2020 agricultural years.
Fig. 1. Rainfall and minimum and maximum temperatures during the oat crop cycle
Table 2. Means of necrotic leaf area (%) in oat cultivars, evaluated at 105 days after emergence, under different fungicide application conditions.
CultivarNLA 2015 (FYD)NLA 2016 (UYD)NLA 2017 (FYD)
CultivarWFCF1CF2CF3WFCF1CF2CF3WFCF1CF2CF3
URS Altiva693072S7630S9863S57S57
URS Brava5314S72S773299716158
URS Guará762090S665498706255
URS Estampa35S2219101387399696653
URS Corona9890802293229960S59S58
URS Torena694118164S2S1S0S99676456
URS Charrua632410418420S98646057
URS Guria621688831S198727162
URS Tarimba5928171120116398686766
URS Taura8926171613530S996557S56
URS 21653017161442298846663
FAEM 007886928241554199746765
FAEM 0069756141418123199736948S
FAEM 5 Chiarasul966014124S32298686866
FAEM 4 Carlasul753316143S2S1S0S986553S43S
Brisasul37S341010632199656059
Barbarasul8682134542199686255
URS Fapa Slava5246241732840S98716860
IPR Afrodite9433445420S9958S56S42S
UPFPS Farroupilha642844864399686355
UPFA Ouro 30S6S551054398797262
UPFA Gaudéria27S15S138642198757268
Mean673716101153199696457
SD222216773210657
Table 2 (continued).
CultivarNLA 2018 (FYD)NLA 2019 (FYD)NLA 2020 (FYD)
CultivarWFCF1CF2CF3WFCF1CF2CF3WFCF1CF2CF3
URS Altiva1009978S77988956S5696949085
URS Brava10010075S73S96916845S939281S81S
URS Guará1001001008810092865599989897
URS Estampa10088S8456S9877S49S46999879S82S
URS Corona10010095929793815597949089
URS Torena1001009881978859S5594939292
URS Charrua10010092889987795498939088
URS Guria10010093909998787498969390
URS Tarimba100100100869594906893919086
URS Taura100989386988952S39S93939088
URS 2110010098939889675999919190
FAEM 00710010099939585706898969595
FAEM 006100100918999887775100999692
FAEM 5 Chiarasul1001008672S9988875099989796
FAEM 4 Carlasul100100827995857623S96959087
Brisasul10010083819068S666597959492
Barbarasul10010084819787646197969285
URS Fapa Slava10010076S759998817096959281S
IPR Afrodite10092S82819375S735595928985
UPFPS Farroupilha10010099989290736893929086
UPFA Ouro 10097848385S70S56S54100969488
UPFA Gaudéria97S96S92849980706597929190
Mean1009989839686715797959188
SD03897811125544

WF= without fungicide; CF1= one fungicide application, at 60 days after emergence (DAE); CF2= two fungicide applications (at 60 and 75 DAE); CF3= three fungicide applications (at 60, 75, and 90 DAE); SD= standard deviation; S= superior, represented by one SD below the mean; FYD= favorable year for the development of foliar diseases; UYD= unfavorable year for the development of foliar diseases.

According to the means of grain yield of oat cultivars under the different fungicide application conditions (Table 3), 2016 stood out, presenting cultivars with higher grains yields than that expected (4,000 kg ha-1), even under absence of fungicide application. This reinforces the occurrence of ideal conditions for cereal cultivation. In general, oat cultivars present increases in grain yield as the number of fungicide applications on a calendar basis is increased.

Some cultivars presented similar grain yield means between the treatments with two and three fungicide applications, as found for necrotic leaf area (Table 2), which may indicate the potential of more significant reductions in the number of fungicide applications.

Regarding the cultivars that exhibited superior grain yield performance (S), represented by one standard deviation above the mean, those that were classified as superior in a specific year under the different fungicide application conditions did not necessarily maintain this trend. However, the cultivars that were consistently classified as superior (S), meaning those with the best performance, regardless of the agricultural year were URS Altiva, FAEM 007, IPR Afrodite, and UPFPS Farroupilha, followed by URS Corona, URS Guria, and UPFA Gaudéria.

Table 3. Means of grain yield of oat cultivars under different fungicide application conditions.
CultivarGY 2015 (AYC)GY 2016 (FYC)GY 2017 (UYC)
CultivarWFCF1CF2CF3WFCF1CF2CF3WFCF1CF2CF3
URS Altiva2321S2696S3487S4236S28933478442344671103165819092109
URS Brava1230239331913993S329837954112422510241539I18822135
URS Guará148620833166345335534067425344871138173620542348
URS Estampa1555239328223302326636253671I3982790I1413I1592I1720I
URS Corona8042030282433333780S4812S4983S5033S97620932424S2499
URS Torena1348237727832892I2861346238864271859I160922172352
URS Charrua16162662S307831073584404841314152983163320832102
URS Guria1949S2681S3413S35172311I3296I377340671150171321192594
URS Tarimba13861646I2672I31603350393442494661910I1303I1541I2119
URS Taura86318132152I2775I2231I3366I414548041069186219742310
URS 211552219230713104331235693662I3755I1025192119482156
FAEM 007579I1194I29222923I3752S4233S4861S4924S1436S2399S2445S2501
FAEM 006749I2035326436603461392941344543134021262444S2586
FAEM 5 Chiarasul727I130433533923S30363783406040091380S191122282432
FAEM 4 Carlasul135221663414S35143802S4127412841821620S2469S2857S3154
Brisasul106622373516S37003362382741724975S1031168320582106
Barbarasul680I18543580S37393358417144534833122017321802I2139
URS Fapa Slava11891719309631592081I3373I3562I3621I954189220142416
IPR Afrodite566I1527I280233824096S4349S4687S5195S1199193824042553
UPFPS Farroupilha132424483215346333543833410444161459S2394S2443S2543
UPFA Ouro 138622902791337827363131I3413I3641I1237190021102362
UPFA Gaudéria130821632601I322230553269I3552I3614I1317190119682072
Mean122920873055340632063794411043571146185621142332
SD448422354368522413413481213304306287
Table 3 (continued).
CultivarGY 2018 (UYC)GY 2019 (UYC)GY 2020 (UYC)
CultivarWFCF1CF2CF3WFCF1CF2CF3WFCF1CF2CF3
URS Altiva1535S19592962S30771097S1409189223561143122814761484
URS Brava1477S2284S3056S29338251550216823681046125414681487
URS Guará1310S200023103012746118619631903I728I140314401465
URS Estampa11732022242631717191712S203421301068134313631708S
URS Corona11531668215029647021142I20182097102513811308I1798S
URS Torena108715192832S30395561308213322781376S1477S1674S1607
URS Charrua7411866239030721026S1553211421441166133014091405
URS Guria670177422192573I5071061I1719I204510881511S1707S1729S
URS Tarimba635I2588S2873S3159655150721452557S568I971I14141489
URS Taura107818632856S3354S645146820432232765870I1275I1307I
URS 211099205721442456I672124818702239753I122814041427
FAEM 007716152322242926678126119551994I801122514601537
FAEM 00677320362438273286715861744I2038990112114141456
FAEM 5 Chiarasul8031369I24452986540I15272273S2358766119913981408
FAEM 4 Carlasul767162621752667572132021142197713I789I1267I1311I
Brisasul67620162261265259413761803I21941009136714781428
Barbarasul72916262446312555513002114226077111541270I1207I
URS Fapa Slava7401567239429925361130I21732266857115014201225I
IPR Afrodite690186124843441S774160520142842S11031516S15401628
UPFPS Farroupilha69116762268273374712831713I20181309S1544S1645S1791S
UPFA Ouro 7971218I1606I2015I1031S14882330S2912S1281S141014671655
UPFA Gaudéria9751236I232931361140S2240S2282S2578S1267S13981625S1635
Mean923178924222919736142120512273982126714511509
SD274331330317190252208258227203125170

GY= grain yield (kg ha-1); WF= without fungicide; CF1= one fungicide application, at 60 days after emergence (DAE); CF2= two fungicide applications (at 60 and 75 DAE); CF3= three fungicide applications (at 60, 75, and 90 DAE); SD= standard deviation; S= superior, represented by one SD above the mean; I= inferior, represented by one SD below the mean; AYC= acceptable year for oat cultivation; FYC= favorable year for oat cultivation; UYC= unfavorable year for oat cultivation.

The compilation of the number of times each cultivar exhibited superiority regarding necrotic leaf area and grain yield in the different agricultural years is shown in Table 4. The cultivars that exhibited the highest number of occurrences of superiority for necrotic leaf area were URS Brava, URS Estampa, and FAEM 4 Carlasul, URS Altiva, and IPR Afrodite. Regarding grain yield, the cultivars that exhibited the highest number of occurrences of superiority were URS Altiva, FAEM 007, IPR Afrodite, UPFPS Farroupilha, URS Corona, URS Guria, and UPFA Gaudéria.

The cultivars FAEM 007 and UPFPS Farroupilha, which stood out in grain yield, did not exhibited superior performance in reducing necrotic leaf area. This suggests that an increase in necrotic leaf area can be offset by a higher physiological efficiency of the remaining healthy cells during the photosynthesis process for grain production. This compensatory effect mechanism may indicate a different form of genetic resistance in plants, a concept also supported by Dornelles et al. (2020) in their study on disease resistance variability in Brazilian oat cultivars under the absence and presence of fungicide applications. Overall, URS Altiva, IPR Afrodite, FAEM 4 Carlasul, URS Brava, and UPFA Gaudéria were the cultivars that most consistently exhibited superior performance for lower necrotic leaf area and higher grain yield.

Table 4. Occurrences of superiority for necrotic leaf area (NLA; %) and grain yield (GY; kg ha⁻¹) of oat cultivars in different agricultural years.
CultivarNLA superiorityΣGY superiorityΣTotal
Cultivar201520162017201820192020Σ201520162017201820192020ΣTotal
URS Altiva1121106400210713
URS Brava2002127100300411
URS Guará100000100010012
URS Estampa100222700001129
URS Corona002000204100168
URS Torena040010500010349
URS Charrua010000110001023
URS Guria010000130000367
URS Tarimba000000000021033
URS Taura011020400020026
URS 21000000000000000
FAEM 007000000004300077
FAEM 006001000100100012
FAEM 5 Chiarasul010100210101035
FAEM 4 Carlasul0420107113000512
Brisasul100010211000024
Barbarasul000000010000011
URS Fapa Slava010101300000003
IPR Afrodite0131106040111713
UPFPS Farroupilha000000000300477
UPFA Ouro 200030500003149
UPFA Gaudéria2002004000042610

Σ= sum of the number of occurrences of superiority; Total= total sum of the number of occurrences of superiority for necrotic leaf area and grain yield.

Linear regression of necrotic leaf area as a function of the number of fungicide applications

The linear regression for necrotic leaf area as a function of the number of fungicide applications in favorable years for foliar disease development showed high linear coefficients (b0) for all evaluated oat cultivars (Table 5). Reduced angular coefficients (b1) were found during these years, mainly in 2018 and 2020, indicating a lower effectiveness of agrochemical control over the expression of leaf necrosis.

The cultivar UPFA Gaudéria stands out for exhibiting superior performance with a smaller necrotic leaf area in at least three agricultural years, followed by URS Torena, URS Tarimba, FAEM 5 Chiarasul, UPFPS Farroupilha, and UPFA Ouro, which showed superior performance for less necrotic leaf area in at least two years. These cultivars are less dependent on the use of fungicides due to necrotic leaf area probably because they have different disease response mechanisms (Table 5).

Table 5. Linear regression of necrotic leaf area (%) as a function of the number of fungicide applications for growing oat cultivars, evaluated at 105 days after emergence.
CultivarNLA 2015 (FYD)NLA 2016 (UYD)NLA 2017 (FYD)
Cultivarb0+b1xR2b0+b1xR2b0+b1xR2
URS Altiva60-22.4*x898-2.5*x9469S-12.8*x71
URS Brava43-16.0*x798-1.9*x9192-13.5*x84
URS Guará62-24.0*x816-0.7x10092-13.8*x88
URS Estampa33S-7.8S*x9512-3.1*x9493-14.2*x87
URS Corona100I-23.6*x807-2.2*x7588-12.4*x65
URS Torena63-18.2*x904S-1.2*x9291-13.3*x82
URS Charrua54-19.1*x8615-5.7I*x7889-12.7*x72
URS Guria49-17.2*x727-2.4*x7392-10.8*x82
URS Tarimba52-15.5*x8919I-5.7I*x9490-10.0S*x66
URS Taura71-22.7*x7112-4.3*x9090-13.7*x77
URS 2155-15.6*x8011-3.8*x7796I-14.2*x93
FAEM 00787I-23.3*x9213-4.2*x8492-10.8*x80
FAEM 00689I-29.1I*x8917I-5.8I*x9595-15.7I*x94
FAEM 5 Chiarasul90I-29.9I*x914S-0.9*x9790-9.6S*x64
FAEM 4 Carlasul64-19.8*x833S-0.8*x9691-17.6I*x90
Brisasul38S-10.4S*x845-1.6*x8790-13.4*x77
Barbarasul94I-31.9I*x865-1.3*x9991-13.7*x84
URS Fapa Slava54-12.9*x9526I-10.1I*x8092-11.8*x82
IPR Afrodite79-30.0I*x835-1.5*x9789-17.3I*x81
UPFPS Farroupilha56-20.3*x858-1.5*x9792-13.6*x85
UPFA Ouro 22S-7.4S*x639-2.0*x8595-11.7*x94
UPFA Gaudéria24S-5.7S*x916-1.5*x92 92-9.3S*x78
Mean61-19.2x10-2.9x91-12.9x
SD 23+7.5x 6+2.3x 5+2.2x
Table 5 (continued).
CultivarNLA 2018 (FYD)NLA 2019 (FYD)NLA 2020 (FYD)
Cultivarb0+b1xR2b0+b1x R2b0+b1xR2
URS Altiva100I-8.7*x8399-15.9*x8797-3.8x98
URS Brava100I-10.4I*x83100I-17.4*x9493S-4.5Ix84
URS Guará100I-3.5x60100-14.0x8499I-0.5Sx97
URS Estampa100I-13.4I*x8995-18.1*x9299I-6.7Ix74
URS Corona100I-2.6S*x89100I-13.9*x8897-2.7x94
URS Torena100I-5.6x6598-15.4*x9293S-0.4Sx70
URS Charrua100I-4.1*x89100I-14.2*x9398-3.4x94
URS Guria100I-3.4x88100I-9.23x8798-2.7x98
URS Tarimba100I-4.0x60100I-8.6Sx7693S-2.0x91
URS Taura100I-4.4x92100I-21.3*x9393S-1.5x89
URS 21100I-2.0S*x8399-14.1*x9697-2.7*x72
FAEM 007100I-1.9S*x6894-9.7x9398-1.1Sx89
FAEM 006100I-3.9*x8397-8.3S*x94100I-2.5x92
FAEM 5 Chiarasul100I-9.6Ix88100I-14.6*x7999I-0.8Sx99
FAEM 4 Carlasul100I-8.1*x85100I-22.4*x8197-3.4x96
Brisasul100I-7.2*x8584S-78x6997-1.6x97
Barbarasul100I-7.1*x8697-13.0*x9399I-4.1Ix88
URS Fapa Slava100I-9.9I*x81100I-10.3*x9196-1.7x88
IPR Afrodite98S-6.5*x9191S-11.4*x9296-3.6x98
UPFPS Farroupilha100I-0.66Sx8394-8.7S*x9093S-2.1x95
UPFA Ouro 100I-6.1x8882S-10.7*x92100I-3.6*x95
UPFA Gaudéria98S-4.2*x9295-11.2x9396-2.1x87
Mean99.9-5.7x97-13.2x97-2.6x
SD1+3.1x7+4.1x2+1,5x

R2= coefficient of determination (%); *= significant at 5% level by the t-test; SD= standard deviation; S= superior, represented by one SD below the mean; I= inferior, represented by one SD above the mean; FYD= favorable year for the development of foliar diseases; UYD= unfavorable year for the development of foliar diseases.

The linear regression for grain yield as a function of the number of fungicide applications showed higher linear coefficients for the cultivars URS Altiva and URS Guria in 2015 (Table 6), as they can achieve grain yields higher than 2,000 kg ha-1 under absence of fungicide application. Regarding angular coefficients, the cultivars FAEM 006, FAEM 5 Chiarasul, Barbarasul, and IPR Afrodite showed a superior rate of grain yield increase with each fungicide application. URS Corona, FAEM 007, FAEM 4 Carlasul, and IPR Afrodite stood out in 2016 for presenting the highest linear coefficients, whereas URS Altiva, URS Guria, and URS Taura presented the highest angular coefficients.

The cultivars FAEM 007, FAEM 4 Carlasul, and UPFPS Farroupilha stood out in 2017 for presenting the highest linear coefficients, whereas URS Corona, URS Torena, URS Guria, FAEM 4 Carlasul, URS Fapa Slava, and IPR Afrodite presented the highest angular coefficients, representing a greater grain yield response to fungicide applications.

In 2018, characterized by significant disease effects on oat crops, superior grain yield was found for the cultivars URS Altiva, URS Brava, URS Guará, and URS 21, according to the linear coefficients; the superior cultivars based on angular coefficients were Barbarasul and IPR Afrodite. URS Altiva also presented superiority for grain yield in 2019 for presenting the highest linear coefficient, along with URS Charrua and UPFA Gaudéria, whereas the cultivars URS Tarimba, FAEM 5 Chiarasul, URS Fapa Slava, IPR Afrodite, and UPFA Ouro were superior for presenting the highest angular coefficients. In 2020, with significant limitations for plant development, higher linear coefficients were found for the cultivars UPFPS Farroupilha, UPFA Ouro, and UPFA Gaudéria, whereas the URS Guará, URS Corona, FAEM 007, and FAEM 4 Carlasul presented the most effective responses to fungicide application for yielding the highest angular coefficients. In summary, URS Altiva, URS Charrua, FAEM 007, FAEM 4 Carlasul, UPFPS Farroupilha, and UPFA Gaudéria showed greater superiority among the analyzed cultivars for presenting higher linear coefficients in most of the evaluated years. However, when considering in an overall analysis encompassing both mean values and linear regression coefficients for smaller necrotic leaf areas and higher grain yields over the years, the cultivars URS Altiva, UPFPS Farroupilha, and UPFA Guria stand out.

Table 6. Linear regression of oat grain yield (GY; kg ha-1) as a function of the number of fungicide applications for growing oat cultivars.
CultivarGY 2015 (AYC)GY 2016 (FYC)GY 2017 (UYC)
Cultivarb0+b1xR2b0+b1x R2 b0+b1xR2
URS Altiva2204S+653*x972964+566S*x911204+326*x93
URS Brava1338+908*x993393+309*x921093+367*x97
URS Guará1499+698*x953641+298*x941226+394*x96
URS Estampa1667+567*x973307+219*x93933I+296I*x86
URS Corona990+838*x964062S+383x741262+490S*x80
URS Torena1594+503I*x852922+465*x98996I+508S*x92
URS Charrua1882S+488I*x823710+178Ix741129+380*x87
URS Guria2075S+543I*x922500I+574S*x921183+474S*x99
URS Tarimba1263+634*x953411+424*x98888I+386*x97
URS Taura989+607*x962361I+849S*x981228+383*x88
URS 211649+553I*x913361+142Ix921249+341*x77
FAEM 007590I+876*x883821S+414*x921709S+324*x67
FAEM 006932+996S*x953499+345*x981515+405*x88
FAEM 5 Chiarasul581I+1163S*x933242+319*x761466+347*x95
FAEM 4 Carlasul1450+773*x923888S+114Ix711776S+499S*x93
Brisasul1252+918*x933306+518*x961179+359*x87
Barbarasul827I+1090S*x923497+470*x941299+282I*x92
URS Fapa Slava1197+728*x902437I+480*x721142+451S*x88
IPR Afrodite610I+972S*x984036S+363*x971344+452S*x92
UPFPS Farroupilha1534+718*x933408+345*x981714S+330*x71
UPFA Ouro 1489+647*x982780+299*x981364+358*x92
UPFA Gaudéria1396+618*x983064+202I*x941465+233I*x78
Mean1319+750x3255+377x1289+378x
SD453+194x483+168x241+70x
Table 6 (continued).
CultivarGY 2018 (UYC)GY 2019 (UYC)GY 2020 (UYC)
Cultivarb0+b1xR2b0+b1x R2 b0+b1xR2
URS Altiva1537S+563*x921030S+456*x981185+170*x94
URS Brava1666S+513I*x83940+524*x941065+183*x98
URS Guará1345S+541*x97812+424I*x87905+274S*x78
URS Estampa1238+639*x98965+455*x831079+193*x91
URS Corona1096+591*x98730+506*x92976+260S*x97
URS Torena1044+716*x92669+599*x931203+175*x93
URS Charrua889+751*x971122S+391I*x901085+160*x92
URS Guria885+615*x92542I+527*x981190+211*x84
URS Tarimba1134+785*x78764+634S*x97648I+240*x91
URS Taura1115+781*x98796+533*x93749I+203*x89
URS 211315S+415*x84708+532*x98862+209*x84
FAEM 007747I+733*x99775+464*x91889+244S*x90
FAEM 0061053+627*x881008+366*x90978+155*x99
FAEM 5 Chiarasul757+762*x98744+620S*x90873+212*x83
FAEM 4 Carlasul871+624*x98700+567*x92632I+297S*x93
Brisasul975+617*x86707+522*x961075+196*x92
Barbarasul780+800S*x99667+592*x93846+219*x92
URS Fapa Slava785+758*x99591I+623S*x92953+133I*x84
IPR Afrodite787+887S*x98866+711S*x961180+150I*x83
UPFPS Farroupilha834+672*x96803+424I*x981357S+154*x94
UPFA Ouro 803+404*x99966+648S*x981240S+131I*x97
UPFA Gaudéria782+757*x951406S+435*x791304S+123I*x90
Mean1020+661x833+524x1010+196x
SD264+125x197+93x200+47x

SD= standard deviation; S= superior, represented by one SD above the mean; I= inferior, represented by one SD below the mean; R2= determination coefficient (%); *= significant at 5% level by the t-test; AYC= acceptable year for oat cultivation; FYC= favorable year for oat cultivation; UYC= unfavorable year for oat cultivation.

Studies have shown that oat cultivars susceptible to the leaf rust fungus can present decreases higher than 50% in grain yield under favorable environmental conditions for the development of this pathogen (Figueiró et al., 2015). Furthermore, the helminthosporiosis (yellow spot) disease reduces grain yield up to 50% under favorable conditions for the fungus (França-Silva et al., 2020). Therefore, the use of cultivars with higher resistance to foliar diseases can contributed to increased grain yield while reducing and/or eliminating the use of pesticides, mainly in agroecological-based cropping systems (Basso et al., 2022). The achievement of the desired standards for white oat crops requires cultivars with high grain yields while meeting the technological standards recommended by the cereal industry, which includes high percentage of caryopsis, a high hectoliter mass, and desirable grain size (Crestani et al., 2010). However, these characteristics may not always be achieved due to climatic factors and the prevalence of fungal diseases (Nerbass Júnior et al., 2008).

The performance of an agronomic species and its potential for large-scale production is conditioned to the presence of a favorable crop environment, which can, however, favor the incidence and pressure of diseases that directly affect grain quality and yield (Silva et al., 2015; Dornelles et al., 2021). Dornelles et al. (2020) emphasized the significant impact of fungicides on increasing grain yield and controlling leaf necrosis caused by foliar diseases in oat plants. The severity of these diseases is often increased by high temperatures and air humidity, which are conditions frequently observed during the flowering and grain filling stages of the crop (Screminn et al., 2023; Rosa et al., 2023). These factors promote the concentration of pesticide applications during these crop development stages, potentially resulting in pesticides residues in the grains and leading to food safety concerns (Pereira et al., 2023). In this context, Alessi et al. (2018) highlighted the importance of evaluating genetic resistance to diseases and the resilience of oat cultivars for reducing the use of fungicide pesticides and improving food safety. Pereira et al. (2023) also highlighted the significance of identifying oat genotypes that exhibit high performance for traits of agronomic and industrial interest while requiring less fungicide applications, with adaptability and stability, promoting safer production. Considering this scenario, the association between the emergence of disease and the use of pesticides, combined with the growing awareness of ecological issues, has caused an increased demand for food produced through more sustainable processes, reflecting changes in consumer preferences based on their increased concerns about health and the environment (Silva et al., 2015; Rosa et al., 2023).

Materials and methods

Study area and experimental design

Field experiments were conducted in Augusto Pestana, RS, Brazil (28°26'30''S and 54°00'58''W) from 2015 to 2020. The soil in the experimental area is classified Typic Hapludox (Latossolo Vermelho Distroferrico tipico; Santos et al., 2018). The region has a humid subtropical climate, according to the Köppen classification. Soil analysis before planting showed the following chemical characteristics: pH = 6.3; P =34.1 mg dm-3; K = 198 mg dm-3; Organic matter (OM) = 3.2%; Al = 0 cmolc dm-3; Ca = 6.5 cmolc dm-3; and Mg = 2.5 cmolc dm-3.

Planting was carried out in the first half of June, using seed-fertilizer drill. Each experimental plot consisted of 5 rows of 5 m long spaced 0.2 m apart, resulting in an experimental unit of 5 m². The population density used was determined according to the technical recommendations for oat crops (400 seeds m-2). Considering the achievement of an expected grain yield of 4 Mg ha-1, 10 kg ha-1 of nitrogen was applied at planting, with the remainder applied as topdressing at the fourth expanded leaf stage. Additionally, 45 and 30 kg ha-1 of P2O5 and K2O were applied at planting, respectively, based on the P and K contents in the soil.

A randomized block experimental design was used, in a 22×4 factorial arrangement consisted of 22 white oat cultivars and 4 fungicide application conditions, with three replications, under a soybean-oat crop system. Oat cultivars recommended for cultivation in Brazil and oat cultivars no longer included in the current recommendations (for use in crossing blocks in the genetic improvement of the species) were evaluated: URS Altiva, URS Brava, URS Guará, URS Estampa, URS Corona, URS Torena, URS Charrua, URS Guria, URS Tarimba, URS Taura, URS 21, FAEM 007, FAEM 006, FAEM 5 Chiarasul, FAEM 4 Carlasul, Brisasul, Barbarasul, URS Fapa Slava, IPR Afrodite, UPFPS Farroupilha, UPFA Ouro, and UPFA Gaudéria. The fungicide application conditions were scheduled as follows: no fungicide application; one application at 60 days after emergence (DAE); two applications: at 60 and 75 DAE; three applications: at 60, 75, and 90 DAE. The last application (90 DAE) was defined to ensure a minimum 30-day interval between fungicide application and grain harvest, with no pesticide application at the grain filling stage, which was visually identified by the transition of the grains from a milky to a pasty (dough) consistency until the loss of green color in the glumes. This procedure was adopted to eliminate or minimize the risk of chemical residue translocation to the grains.

The fungicide applied was FOLICUR CE at a rate 0.75 L ha-1, (active ingredient: tebuconazole; class: systemic from the triazoles group; formulation: emulsifiable concentrate). Spraying to the plots was carried out using a BD 04 fan nozzle at a pressure of 45 PSI for an application volume of 120 L ha-1. A pH reducer of 30 ml ha-1 and Nimbus mineral oil at 0.5 L ha-1 were added to all treatments. Weed control involved the application of metsulfuron-methyl Ally at 4 g ha⁻¹, with additional manual weeding as needed. No insecticide applications were required as insect pest populations remained below the economic injury level throughout the study. Regarding diseases, only the foliar pathogens under evaluation were managed as part of the experimental treatments, with no other significant phytosanitary issues observed.

Variables analyzed

The percentage of necrotic leaf area (NLA) was determined using three randomly collected plants from each plot. Plants were collected at 60, 75, 90, and 105 DAE for of all cultivars and fungicide application conditions. The three upper leaves from each collected plant were removed and evaluated for leaf area. These leaves were taken to a laboratory and digitalized, and the images were analyzed using a leaf area reader and the software WinDIAS (Copyright 2012, Delta-T Devices Limited) to determine necrosis caused by the disease on the total leaf area. The three central rows of each plot were considered for estimating grain yield, with mechanical harvesting performed when grains moisture content was approximately 15%. Grains were taken to the laboratory for moisture correction to 13%, followed by threshing and weighing to obtain the grain yield in grams, which was converted to kg ha-1.

Oat cultivars were classified as superior (S) and inferior (I) based on their performance regarding necrotic leaf area and grain yield in each agricultural year scenario, considering one standard deviation (SD) above or below the mean (mean±SD). Regarding necrotic leaf area, S cultivars were those presenting one SD below the mean (mean−SD), whereas I cultivars were those with one SD above the mean (mean+SD). Regarding grain yield, S and I cultivars were those with mean+SD and mean−SD, respectively. Additionally, the cultivars that yielded the best results in terms of necrotic leaf area and grain yield, regardless of the agricultural year, were determined by quantifying the total means classified as superior for each cultivar.

Statistical analysis and multiple linear regression

Necrotic leaf area and grain yield data were subjected to analysis of variance to assess the main and interaction effects between the factors (oat cultivar and fungicide application condition) in each agricultural year (not shown). Subsequently, linear regression analysis was performed, using the equation (Y=b0+b1x), to describe the relationship between necrotic leaf area and grain yield with the number of fungicide applications. The performance of oat cultivars was assessed through analysis of the magnitude of the linear equation parameters, classifying the intercept (bo) as superior (S) and inferior (I), which indicates the starting point of the variable in the regression; the angular coefficient (b1) was also assessed, which indicates the variable's growth rate as a function of the number of fungicide applications. The criterion considered for evaluating these parameters was based on one standard deviation above or below the overall mean. Statistical analyses were performed considering an significance level of 5%, using the free software GENES (Cruz, 2013).

Conclusion

The analyses of necrotic leaf area and grain yield revealed that the Brazilian oat cultivars most resilient to reduced fungicide use, with no application during the grain filling stage, were URS Altiva, UPFPS Farroupilha, and UPFA Gaudéria. Therefore, these cultivars have significant potential as genetic resources for promoting food security or for cultivation in agroecological production systems.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank the Brazilian Coordination for the Improvement of Higher Education Personnel (CAPES), the Brazilian National Council for Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq), and the Foundation for Research Support of the State of Rio Grande do Sul (FAPERGS) for their financial support by granting Scientific and Technological Initiation Scholarships, Postgraduate Scholarships, and Research Productivity Scholarships. The authors also thank the Dubai Alimentos company and the Postgraduate Program in Mathematical and Computational Modeling and Environmental Systems and Sustainability at the Regional University of the Northwest of the State of Rio Grande do Sul (UNIJUI) for providing resources for the development of this research.

References

Cite this article

Alessi O et al. (2026) Less dependent Brazilian oat cultivars to fungicides during the grain filling stage. Aust J Crop Sci. 20(11):958–971. https://doi.org/10.21475/ajcs.26.20.11.pne226